1.Introduction
In the modern economic world, despite the complexity of financial instruments and the multiplicity of investment alternatives, gold still retains its unique position as a "psychological sanctuary" before it is a financial sanctuary. It does not give the investor a material return as much as it gives him a sense of reassurance in the face of the unknown. Hence, the close relationship between human psychology and the movement of gold markets, where buying and selling decisions oscillate between two conflicting instincts: fear and greed.
This paper aims to analyze how these two instincts are embodied in investment behavior, and how individual emotions turn into collective waves that change market trends, ultimately revealing that gold prices not only reflect economic reality, but also the psychological mood of societies. By reviewing evidence from contemporary crises such as the 2008 global financial crisis and the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic, the study seeks to understand why gold becomes a psychological refuge par excellence whenever confidence in the financial system is shaken, and how its rise expresses the pulse of collective fear in individuals and institutions alike.
2.The Psychological Dimension of Investing - Between the Fear and Greed Instincts
Human emotions play a crucial role in investment decisions: In periods of economic and market booms, investors are optimistic and greedy and seek higher returns in risky assets (stocks, real estate, etc.), leading to a relative aversion to gold, which is perceived as a low-yielding protective asset.For example, during the market boom between 2003 and 2007, we saw a decline in investment demand for gold as investors rushed to global equities, which made strong gains. In periods of crisis and recession, fear and uncertainty prevail, and investors flee from risk and take refuge in safe havens, especially gold.We saw in the 2008-2009 financial crisis how the price of gold rose by more than 60% during 2008 and 2009 despite the collapse of stocks(Investopedia, 2022) - thecollective fear of the collapse of the banking system and the dollar drove the migration of money to gold as a last resort.Similarly, at the height of the COVID-19 scare in March 2020, investment flows into gold ETFs jumped to record levels (+300 tons during Q1 2020) driven by investors seeking protection, with total gold ETF holdings around the world reaching a record 3,185 tons in April 2020(World Gold Council, 2023).
This cyclical swing is known in behavioral finance as the Greed&Fear Cycle.Markets generally go through cycles of excessive optimism (greed) that drives prices to exaggerated levels, followed by a correction or crash as confidence dissipates and pessimism (fear) rises that may drop prices below their fair values, then confidence gradually returns and the cycle repeats.Gold as a mirror of financial security is strongly affected at both ends of this cycle. At the peak of greed, when investors believe that "everything is fine" and risks are under control, the share of gold in portfolios declines because the incentive to hedge is weakened - this is what happened, for example, in the mid-1980s and late 1990s as real gold prices fell and the importance of holding it declined.At the height of fear, when there is a sense that "disaster is imminent" and other assets are risky, demand for gold swells regardless of its price because it becomes the ultimate psychological refuge.Hence, gold has been described as a "collective fear indicator" in the market: the higher the level of fear (of a financial crisis, war, or banking collapse), the higher the demand for gold and the higher its price. For example, in one week of March 2020 - the peak of the coronavirus shock - global investors poured about 7.9 billion dollars into goldETFs, an unprecedented weekly inflow at the time(World Gold Council, 2023),in parallel with a massive sell-off in equity markets. In that week, the VIXfear indexreached over 80 points (a panic level), while gold broke the $1700 barrier for the first time since 2012. So there is a strong psychological correlation: greed pulls liquidity away from gold, and fear pushes liquidity towards gold.
Financial media and the news cycle play a pivotal role in reinforcing feelings of fear or greed. When markets are rising, the media is filled with get-rich-quick stories and "miss the boat" advice, fuelingFOMO(fear of missing out) and pushing investors to take more risk and disregard hedging. Gold is less in demand at these times as it is perceived as restricting capital from profit opportunities.On the other hand, during crises, negative headlines and catastrophic rumors dominate the news 24/7, amplifying the public's feelings of fear and uncertainty. In such an atmosphere, we often see media reports recommending buying gold and "sheltering in place" and images of people flocking to gold bullion and coin shops. The media creates collective psychological waves that drive prices: it fuels greed on the upside and fear on the downside, intensifying the cycle.
3.Confidence and fear in the global financial system
Gold price rises globally are often linked to the erosion of confidence in financial institutions and fiat currencies. When investors and the public's confidence in traditional markets (stocks, bonds, banks) or the ability of monetary authorities to manage the economy is shaken, many turn to gold as a last resort.We have seen this clearly during the major financial crises of the modern era. In the 2008 global financial crisis in which Lehman Brothers collapsed and the US banking system nearly collapsed, confidence in the financial system was so low that gold prices rose from around $800 in 2007 to $1,900 in September 2011(Investopedia, 2022).This period was accompanied by government bailout programs and massive amounts of money printing (quantitative stimulus), sparking fears of dollar devaluation. Many investors felt that fiat currencies could lose value as a result of government spending and debt, and turned to gold to preserve their wealth. The 2009-2011 gold buying spree was arguably an expression of the collective distrust of Wall Street and central banks following the crisis(Council on Foreign Relations [CFR], 2023).
In the 2020 COVID-19 crisis, when lockdown measures led to a global recession and trillions of dollars in economic support, there was a sense that the economic system was entering uncharted territory. Investors of all sizes rushed to gold: its price rose from around $1,500 in early 2020 to a historic peak of around $2,070 in August 2020(Reuters, 2023).This was driven by many believing that QE would cause hyperinflation or monetary collapse, and thus losing faith in the long-term stability of the dollar and euro, choosing gold as a store of value not dependent on the promises of any government(World Gold Council, 2023).
When individuals or even governments are afraid of unforeseen events - a large-scale war, a global pandemic, a major banking collapse - gold is like a lighthouse in a sea of darkness. It is a physical asset that has existed since ancient times, historically maintaining its purchasing power in the most severe crises (world wars, the Great Depression), and is therefore seen as the ultimate safety net when other nets fail.For example, during a local currency crisis or a massive price hike, we see ordinary citizens rushing to buy gold to protect their small savings. This has happened in countries that faced a collapse in their currency (such as Venezuela 2018 or Lebanon 2020) where gold shops were crowded with people wanting to convert their savings into gold when they lost faith in the currency and the banks.
The 2022 surge in gold purchases to a half-century high was accompanied by a global crisis of confidence: a European war, sanctions, high inflation, and geopolitical disputes(World Gold Council, 2023).Similarly, the 1980 gold rally followed the difficult decade of the 1970s when confidence in the dollar's ability to curb inflation was lost.Gold can be likened to a "confidence scale" that rises as people's confidence in institutions falls. As one bank's chief investment strategist put it: "When you see gold prices soaring even though there is no shortage of supply or new industrial demand, you know the issue is elsewhere-in people's hearts and minds."In other words, people buy gold not because it grows or produces profits, but because it makes them feel safe when they don't feel safe in anything else. In this context, it can rightly be said that "gold is an indicator of collective fear": its sharp rise means that many individuals and institutions are losing faith in the authorities' plans and the future of the economy, and its sharp fall means the return of reassurance and perhaps some complacency. It is a psychological compass that indicates the direction of the general mood: excessive optimism or excessive pessimism.
4.Crowd psychology and collective behavior in the gold market
The gold market, like any other market, is subject to the effects of Herd Behavior, where the decisions of isolated individuals turn into collective waves of buying or selling that lead to large price fluctuations. The idea here is that an individual investor may make a decision more influenced by the decisions of others than by his own analysis, especially in uncertain markets. In the case of gold, which is often bought with an emotional motive (fear or greed as mentioned above), the susceptibility to engage in herd behavior is high.
How do these waves form? Suppose a crisis starts - financial or geopolitical - and a number of large investors shift part of their portfolios into gold (a hedging move). The media picks up on this and starts talking about the "return of gold". Other investors hear the news and fear being left behind or exposed to risk, so they do the same and buy gold.As demand grows, the price rises, attracting new investors (even those who weren't so convinced at first) who see the price going up and are afraid of missing out - more people join the buying wave. The wave grows like a snowball. Rumors, recommendations, and influencers act as accelerators.A rumor that "an Asian central bank intends to buy 100 tons of gold" may prompt speculators to buy gold contracts in anticipation of a rally, potentially self-fulfilling the prophecy. Statements from famous investors (such as a large fund manager announcing that he has increased his exposure to gold) influence small investors who may imitate the "big boys".In the age of social media, investment recommendations spread at lightning speed. A post on Twitter or a financial forum stating that "a massive gold rally is coming" is enough for thousands of small traders to rush to buy, sometimes creating instant price jumps. This method of crowd influence is well known and has led to bubbles in several markets (most recently meme stocks and cryptocurrencies). Gold is less extreme because it is a huge market, but psychological waves remain a major factor in its movement.
Let's look at historical case studies that illustrate the behavior of crowds in the gold market:
First, the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: its beginnings saw a similar pattern - an initial sell-off of all assets, including gold, in March 2020 to increase liquidity (gold fell from around $1650 to $1450 in just a few days), and then went on a record rally as investors realized the scale of the health and economic crisis(World Gold Council, 2023).Central bank policies (zero interest rate cuts and massive quantitative easing) encouraged the public to go to gold to protect against expected inflation (World Gold Council, 2023).The lockdown also played a role in guiding the behavior of the crowds: as millions of people sat at home and watched the alarming news, their interest in alternative investments increased. Indeed, Google searches for buying gold and gold coins rose dramatically in 2020. Many people who had never bought gold before decided to buy in that period as a refuge.The result: Gold rose by about 35% in less than 6 months, reaching a historic high price in August 2020(Reuters, 2023).It can be said that those months represented the peak of collective fear globally since World War II, and gold was the biggest beneficiary as a global herd behavior towards refuge.
During the first weeks of the war and the escalation of talk about the possibility of wider confrontations and possibly tactical nuclear use, there was feverish demand for gold in Europe and Russia. Europeans feared the extension of the war and the resulting economic uncertainty (especially with the energy crisis), so individual buying of bars and currencies increased significantly in Germany and Britain. In Russia, after the ruble first collapsed, citizens queued up in front of exchange houses and gold shops to buy as much gold and dollars as they could.According to local reports, sales of small gold bars in Moscow increased more than 6 times in March 2022 compared to the previous year. This collective behavior supported the global gold price, which reached $2,070 per ounce on March 8, 2022, very close to its record high(Reuters, 2023).Even after the panic subsided and prices stabilized around $1,800-1900 for the rest of the year, investment demand for gold remained higher than average, driven by continued geopolitical uncertainty.
5.Conclusion
Analysis of individual and institutional behavior in times of crisis shows that gold is not bought with reason alone, but above all with emotion. Its rise does not always reflect a lack of supply or a fundamental change in its physical value, but rather shifts in the collective psychological mood that governs the human relationship with risk and trust. When fear prevails and certainty is absent, gold becomes a tangible representation of safety; when optimism and greed prevail, interest in it declines in favor of assets that promise higher returns.
Historical experience - from the 2008 crisis to the 2020 coronavirus pandemic to the Russian-Ukrainian war - has shown that demand for gold increases as confidence in the global financial system erodes.In essence, gold is not just a financial asset driven by indices and prices, but a psychological indicator of the depth of collective anxiety about the economic future. It embodies what could be called a "psychological refuge," as people buy the yellow metal not for gain, but to regain a sense of control in a turbulent world.
The paper also showed that the media, crowds and cultural heritage all contribute to the formation of recurring psychological cycles of fear and greed, making the movement of gold a mirror of the cycle of human emotion itself. In moments of panic, the decisions of individuals, despite their different cultural and economic backgrounds, are united in a collective rush towards gold as if they are responding to a common primitive instinct: the instinct of financial survival.
The value of gold transcends market equations; it is an accurate measure of the degree of confidence in the future and the internal security of societies. Understanding the dynamics of fear and greed in investor behavior not only helps explain gold price fluctuations, but also reveals the deep nature of man when faced with the unknown - a man who, amidst the chaos of the world, always seeks something that shines and does not disappear.
To watch the video and download the paper, please scroll down
Comments